The biggest leadership risk in your organization right now isn’t your bad leaders. After all, you know who the bad leaders are, and so does everyone else. They generate complaints, miss numbers and eventually get managed out.
The real risk is the leaders nobody’s got on their radar, the competent, well-meaning leaders who hit their targets and don’t make waves. Executive leaders might describe these leaders as “solid,” “reliable” or “doing fine.”
And yet, they are far from meeting today’s workforce’s needs. They produce what could be called “quiet failure” in the workforce. Rather than inspiring their teams or driving momentum, these leaders produce teams that are just going through the motions. As our recent research with The Harris Poll concludes, these kinds of leaders are the biggest risk to organizational success. Plus, companies aren’t tracking this shortcoming, at their own peril.
What quiet failure actually looks like
When leadership goes wrong loudly, it’s easy to spot. Typically, there’s a scandal, a launch that flames out publicly or a senior departure that lands in the trade press. Action follows because the problem is obvious.
Quiet failure is different. It often looks like this:
Initiatives that launch with fanfare and die through neglect
Engagement scores that consistently drift down a couple of points a year
Talent refreshing their LinkedIn profile
Decisions that get made and then revisited. And revisited again
Meetings where everyone nods, no one commits and nothing actually changes
None of this necessarily leads to a leader getting fired. But this kind of dynamic slowly erodes the trust, momentum, and discretionary effort your success depends on, especially in the age of AI, constant uncertainty and change.
The uncomfortable truth about your “good” leaders
We surveyed 2,206 employed Americans about their bosses. The numbers tell a story most executive teams don’t want to hear.
Only 30% of leaders are rated as exceptional. Sixteen percent are outdated, still operating from a playbook that no longer works. The biggest group, by far, is the 54% who are rated merely “good.”
Here’s the part that should keep you up at night. We asked employees how they actually feel working for their leaders. Under good leaders:
Only 16% feel that what is important to them is valued.
Only 19% feel heard.
Only 14% feel they are reaching their potential.
Translation: under your “good” leaders, four out of five people are showing up but not investing in their future. These leaders are not generating complaints or showing up in your exit interview data yet. But they are slowly causing real damage to your ability to succeed.
These merely good leaders aren’t equipped to lead in today’s operating environment, with AI disruption, restructuring, geopolitical instability and economic volatility ruling the day. Gallup’s latest State of the Global Workplace report found global employee engagement fell to 20% in 2025, its lowest level since 2020.
Why today’s leaders need to do better
Good leaders aren’t failing on purpose. That’s what makes this so hard to see.
Most leaders today were trained for stability. Providing clarity and direction when there’s a straightforward path, or passing on information at a controlled pace, worked in the past. But today’s environment doesn’t reward leaders who only know how to lead when the path is obvious.
Amid so much change and uncertainty, good leaders go quiet because they don’t know what to say. They’ve been taught that leaders are supposed to have answers, so in the absence of answers, they retreat into task management and hope the uncertainty resolves on its own.
Their teams experience this as distance. Sure, their leaders are still sending emails and running meetings. Yet there’s little sense that someone is paying attention and has your back. That’s how quiet failure starts, not with a bad leader but with a good one who didn’t know how to show up in the way people actually needed.
What leaders can do about the changing needs of their workforce
Most executive teams treat leadership development as an investment in people who are doing fine. That’s the wrong frame. In an environment defined by uncertainty, leader capability isn’t a “growth” line item. It’s risk mitigation, on par with cybersecurity or business continuity.
To start getting on a better path, here’s what leaders can start doing this week.
Reframe what you measure: If the only things you watch are engagement scores and voluntary attrition, you’re reading lagging indicators. By the time those numbers move, the damage is done. Look at leading indicators instead, such as initiative velocity, and whether decisions stick or get revisited every other week. Also consider whether communication is calibrated to what employees actually need to hear, or only to what leaders want to say.
Ask different questions: “How’s your team doing?” gets you “fine.” “What are you carrying that I don’t know about?” gets you the truth. “What context am I missing?” opens a window into what’s actually slowing things down. Quiet failure thrives in conversations that stop at “good.”
Get specific about gratitude: Our research found that gratitude is the No. 1 differentiator between exceptional leaders and everyone else. But here’s the catch: it has to be about the person, not just the work. Twenty-five years of sitting in rooms with executive teams has taught me one thing about appreciation: leaders almost always believe they’re doing more of it than their teams feel they are. “Great job, team” might check a box, but it doesn’t actually resonate. What lands is when a leader notices who someone is, not just what they produced. “I know this project connects to what you care about. Tell me how it’s going, not just the work, but for you.” That’s the difference between feeling appreciated and feeling truly seen.
Drop the armor: Most leaders were trained to project certainty even when they don’t have it.: “I don’t know yet, and here’s what I’m doing to figure it out.” Vulnerability isn’t weakness. It’s the precondition for trust.
The reframe
Good leaders are the problem. And, they’re also the solution.
It isn’t about replacing leaders but equipping them. The same people quietly leading employees to drift can also generate momentum, but only if you give them the capabilities this environment actually demands. That’s the work in front of you.
Quiet failure won’t show up in your inbox tomorrow with a flashing red light. It’ll show up six months from now, in a strategy meeting, when someone realizes the transformation wasn’t effective, the talent has thinned and nobody can quite explain how it happened.
By the time it’s loud enough to demand attention, you’ve already paid for it.
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
____________________________________
Take advantage of SmartBrief’s FREE email newsletters on leadership and business transformation, among the company’s more than 250 industry-focused newsletters.
